Skip to main content

How to Resolve Error "CS0146: Circular base class dependency involving 'class1' and 'class2'" in C#

The Compiler Error CS0146 is a structural logic error. The message reads: "Circular base class dependency involving 'ClassA' and 'ClassB'".

Inheritance in C# must be hierarchical (a tree structure). A Child class inherits from a Parent class. If you create a loop where the Parent inherits from the Child (or the Child inherits from itself), the compiler enters an infinite loop trying to determine the definition of the types. Since a class cannot be its own ancestor, the compiler blocks this logical impossibility.

This guide explains how these loops occur and how to break them.

Understanding Circular Dependency​

When Class A inherits from Class B, Class A gets all of B's members. If Class B also inherits from Class A, then B gets all of A's members. Since A contains B, and B contains A, A effectively contains itself infinitely.

The compiler needs to calculate the memory layout and Method Table for the base class before it can finish the derived class. In a circle, there is no "first" class to finish, causing the error.

Scenario 1: Self-Inheritance (The Simplest Loop)​

This is usually a typo where a developer copies the class name and accidentally pastes it into the inheritance spot.

Example of error​

// ⛔️ Error CS0146: Circular base class dependency involving 'SelfAbsorbed' and 'SelfAbsorbed'
public class SelfAbsorbed : SelfAbsorbed
{
    // A class cannot be its own father.
}

Solution​

Inherit from the correct base class, or nothing (implicitly System.Object).

// ✅ Correct: Inherits from nothing (System.Object)
public class SelfAbsorbed
{
}

Scenario 2: Two-Way Inheritance (The Ping-Pong)​

This scenario often happens when two classes are tightly coupled, and the developer gets confused about which one should be the base.

Example of error​

File: Parent.cs

// Parent tries to inherit from Child
public class Parent : Child 
{
}

File: Child.cs

// Child tries to inherit from Parent
// ⛔️ Error CS0146: Circular dependency between Parent and Child
public class Child : Parent
{
}

Solution​

Establish a clear hierarchy. One must be the base, and the other the derived.

// ✅ Correct: Parent is the base
public class Parent
{
}

// ✅ Correct: Child inherits from Parent
public class Child : Parent
{
}

Scenario 3: Generic Class Loops​

While C# allows a pattern called Curiously Recurring Template Pattern (CRTP) (e.g., class Node : Base<Node>), you can still trigger CS0146 if the inheritance chain forms a closed loop between distinct types.

Example of error​

// Class A inherits from B
public class A : B { }

// Class B inherits from a Generic version of A
// ⛔️ Error CS0146: Circular dependency.
// To define A, we need B. To define B, we need Generic<A>. 
// To define Generic<A>, we need A. Loop closed.
public class B : GenericWrapper<A> { }

public class GenericWrapper<T> { }

Solution​

Review your architecture. Usually, GenericWrapper should be the base for both, or A should not inherit from B.

// ✅ Correct: Both inherit from the wrapper independently
public class A : GenericWrapper<A> { }
public class B : GenericWrapper<B> { }

Solution: Break the Chain or Use Composition​

If you feel like Class A needs functionality from B, and B needs functionality from A, Inheritance is likely the wrong tool. Use Composition instead.

Instead of "A is a B", say "A has a B".

Using Composition​

public class Teacher
{
    // Teacher HAS A Student reference, but is not a Student
    public Student FavoriteStudent { get; set; }
}

public class Student
{
    // Student HAS A Teacher reference, but is not a Teacher
    public Teacher HomeRoomTeacher { get; set; }
}

This allows two classes to reference each other without creating a type-definition loop.

Conclusion​

CS0146 is the compiler preventing a logical paradox.

  1. Check Typos: Did you accidentally make a class inherit from itself?
  2. Check Hierarchy: Draw your classes on a piece of paper. If the arrows form a circle, the design is invalid.
  3. Use Composition: If two classes depend on each other, they should hold references to each other (Has-A), not inherit from each other (Is-A).

Table of Contents