Skip to main content

How to Resolve Error "CS0178: Invalid rank specifier: expected ',' or ']'" in C#

The Compiler Error CS0178 is a syntax error regarding Array Declaration. The message reads: "Invalid rank specifier: expected ',' or ']'".

In C#, arrays are declared using square brackets []. The "rank" refers to the number of dimensions (1D, 2D, 3D, etc.). This error occurs when you try to specify the size of the array on the left-hand side (the variable type declaration), or when you malform the initialization of a jagged array.

This guide explains the correct syntax for declaring and initializing C# arrays.

Understanding Array Declaration Rules​

In C#, the separation between the Type and the Instance is strict.

  • Declaration (Type): Describes the shape of the array (e.g., int[], int[,]). It never includes the size.
  • Initialization (Instance): Allocates the memory. This is where you specify the size (e.g., new int[5]).

CS0178 triggers when you put numbers (sizes) inside the brackets of the variable declaration.

Scenario 1: Specifying Size in the Declaration​

This is the most common mistake, especially for developers coming from C or C++. You try to declare "an array of 10 integers" by putting 10 in the variable type.

Example of error​

public class Data
{
    // ⛔️ Error CS0178: Invalid rank specifier: expected ',' or ']'
    // You cannot specify '10' here. The type is just 'int[]'.
    int[10] numbers; 
}

Solution: Move Size to Initialization​

Keep the variable type empty ([]) and define the size on the right-hand side using new.

public class Data
{
    // ✅ Correct: Declaration uses [], Initialization uses [10]
    int[] numbers = new int[10];
}

Scenario 2: Incorrect Jagged Array Initialization​

A Jagged Array is an "array of arrays" (int[][]). When initializing a jagged array, you can only specify the size of the outer array (the "rows"). You cannot specify the size of the inner arrays in the same step, because each inner array must be allocated individually (and can be different sizes).

Example of error​

Trying to allocate the whole grid in one go.

public void SetupGrid()
{
    // ⛔️ Error CS0178: Invalid rank specifier.
    // C# cannot automate the creation of the sub-arrays like this.
    int[][] grid = new int[5][5]; 
}

Solution: Initialize Outer Dimension Only​

Allocate the main array first, then loop through to allocate sub-arrays (or use shorthand initialization).

public void SetupGrid()
{
    // ✅ Correct: Allocate the 5 rows first. 
    // The columns (second bracket) must remain empty here.
    int[][] grid = new int[5][];

    // Manually initialize inner arrays
    for (int i = 0; i < grid.Length; i++)
    {
        grid[i] = new int[5];
    }
}

Scenario 3: Mixing Rectangular and Jagged Syntax​

C# supports Multi-dimensional (Rectangular) arrays using commas (int[,]) and Jagged arrays using multiple brackets (int[][]). Mixing the syntax causes CS0178.

Example of error​

Using comma syntax in the declaration but bracket syntax in the initialization (or vice versa).

public void CreateMatrix()
{
    // ⛔️ Error CS0178: Syntax confusion.
    // 'int[5][5]' is for jagged arrays. 'int[ , ]' is for rectangular.
    int[ , ] matrix = new int[5][5]; 
}

Solution: Choose One Style​

Option A: Rectangular Matrix (Fixed Dimensions) Use commas for both declaration and initialization.

// ✅ Correct: 5x5 fixed grid
int[ , ] matrix = new int[5, 5];

Option B: Jagged Array (Flexible Dimensions) Use double brackets for declaration, and single size for initialization.

// ✅ Correct: An array of 5 arrays
int[][] jagged = new int[5][];
note

Which one to use?

  • Use int[,] (Rectangular) for mathematical matrices or grids where every row is the same length.
  • Use int[][] (Jagged) if you need rows of different lengths or are working with JSON-like structures.

Conclusion​

CS0178 is strictly a syntax error regarding the square brackets [].

  1. Variable Side: Never put numbers inside the brackets on the left side (int[5] x is invalid).
  2. Jagged Arrays: You can only set the first size: new int[5][]. You cannot set new int[5][5].
  3. Rectangular Arrays: Use commas: new int[5, 5].

Table of Contents